#### George M. Ratner, appellee, v. M. Kaplan, appellant.

Gen. No. 24,633.

Action to recover for services rendered as auditor and accountant. Judgment for plaintiff against one defendant, and dismissal as to the other. Appeal from the Municipal Court of Chicago; the Hon. John F. Haas, Judge, presiding. Heard in the Branch Appellate Court at the October term, 1918.

Affirmed.

Opinion filed October 10, 1919.

George B. Cohen, for appellant; Joseph H. Lawler, of counsel. Andalman & Cohen and Philip B. Levitón, for appellee.

Mr.- Justice Gridley

delivered the opinion of the court.