#### John J. Ryan, appellee, v. Charles E. Frazier et al., as Civil Service Commissioners, appellants.

Gen. No. 28,234.

Petition for certiorari against Civil Service Commissioners of Chicago to certify their proceedings involving petitioner’s discharge as a Civil Service employee. Return filed. Motion to quash return sustained. Motion to quash writ and dismiss petition denied. Appeal from the Circuit Court of Cook county; the Hon. P. L. Sullivan, Judge, presiding. Heard in the third division of ‘this court for the first district at the October term, 1922.

Affirmed.

Opinion filed June 20, 1923.

Rehearing denied July 3, 1923.

Samuel A. Ettelson, Corporation Counsel, for appellants; Gilbert G.' Ogden, Assistant Corporation Counsel, of counsel. Michael F. Ryan, for appellee.

Mr. Presiding Justice Thomson

delivered the opinion of the court.