#### The Carbic Manufacturing Company, appellee, v. The Osgood Company, appellant.

Gen. No. 28,367.

Suit by employee to recover money paid by him as office rent. Judgment for plaintiff. Appeal from the Municipal Court of Chicago; the Hon. F. J. Campbell, Judge, presiding. Heard in the second division of this court for the first district at the March 1923.

Affirmed.

Opinion filed October 2, 1923.

Harry J. Myerson and Don C. Wray, for appellant; John H. Bart-ram, of counsel. Cattell & Waldron, for appellee; Ralph E. Brown, of counsel.

Mr. Justice Fitch

delivered the opinion of the court.