#### Esther Joy, plaintiff-appellee, v. City of Chicago, defendant-appellant.

Gen. No. 32,984.

Opinion filed February 27, 1929.

Samuel A. Ettelson, Corporation Counsel and William D. Saltiel, City Attorney, for appellant; Charles M. McDonnell, Assistant City Attorney, E. Marshall, Amberg and Roy S. Gaskill, Assistant Corporation Counsel, of counsel. James H. Turner and Irwin M. Baker, for appellee.

Mr. Justice Wilson

delivered the opinion of the court.