#### Clara A. Crozier, complainant, v. Freeman Coal Mining Company et al., defendants. James W. McElvain et al., cross complainants, appellees, v. Freeman Coal Mining Company et al., cross defendants, on appeal of Maclay Hoyne, appellant.

Gen. No. 36,662.

Opinion filed February 7, 1934.

Winston, Strawn & Shaw, for appellant; John D. Black, of counsel. Kemper K. Knapp, for certain appellee. John J. Healy and John H. S. Lee, for certain other appellees.

Mr. Justice Wilson

delivered the opinion of the court.