(No. 22858.

#### Telesforo Novarro, Appellee, vs. The Illinois Steel Company, Appellant.

Opinion filed April 17, 1935.

Knapp, Beye, Allen & Cushing, (Joseph L. Early-wine, and Paul R. Conaghan, of counsel,) for appellant.

McKenna, Harris & Schneider, and Sol Andrews, for appellee.

Samuel A. Ettelson, amicus curies.

Mr. Justice Orr

delivered the opinion of the court:

This is a companion case to Parks v. Libby-Owens-Ford Glass Co. (ante, p. 130,) Boshuizen v. Thompson & Taylor Co. (ante, p. 160,) and Vallat v. Radium Dial Co. (ante, p. 407,) decided at this term. The facts, although differing in detail, are in substance the same. The same constitutional questions are involved. The circuit court of Cook county rendered judgment, in accordance with a jury verdict, against appellant for damages in the sum of $20,000, and from this judgment the present appeal was taken.

Upon the authority of our holdings in the three above named cases the judgment of the circuit court was erroneous, and it is therefore reversed.

Judgment reversed.