{
  "id": 8525026,
  "name": "TERESA M. P. JONES and LOUISE BLANCHARD JONES, Co-Administratrixes of the Estate of KIM BLANCHARD JONES, Deceased v. FOSTER McCASKILL, III",
  "name_abbreviation": "Jones v. McCaskill",
  "decision_date": "1990-08-07",
  "docket_number": "No. 8915SC1117",
  "first_page": "764",
  "last_page": "767",
  "citations": [
    {
      "type": "official",
      "cite": "99 N.C. App. 764"
    }
  ],
  "court": {
    "name_abbreviation": "N.C. Ct. App.",
    "id": 14983,
    "name": "North Carolina Court of Appeals"
  },
  "jurisdiction": {
    "id": 5,
    "name_long": "North Carolina",
    "name": "N.C."
  },
  "cites_to": [
    {
      "cite": "295 S.E.2d 480",
      "category": "reporters:state_regional",
      "reporter": "S.E.2d",
      "year": 1982,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "the purpose of wrongful death compensatory damages is to restore the beneficiaries to the position they would have occupied had there been no death"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0
    },
    {
      "cite": "306 N.C. 744",
      "category": "reporters:state",
      "reporter": "N.C.",
      "case_ids": [
        8574149,
        8574186,
        8574160,
        8574203,
        8574172
      ],
      "year": 1982,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "the purpose of wrongful death compensatory damages is to restore the beneficiaries to the position they would have occupied had there been no death"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0,
      "case_paths": [
        "/nc/306/0744-01",
        "/nc/306/0744-04",
        "/nc/306/0744-02",
        "/nc/306/0744-05",
        "/nc/306/0744-03"
      ]
    },
    {
      "cite": "293 S.E.2d 843",
      "category": "reporters:state_regional",
      "reporter": "S.E.2d",
      "year": 1982,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "the purpose of wrongful death compensatory damages is to restore the beneficiaries to the position they would have occupied had there been no death"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0
    },
    {
      "cite": "58 N.C. App. 551",
      "category": "reporters:state",
      "reporter": "N.C. App.",
      "case_ids": [
        8525518
      ],
      "year": 1982,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "the purpose of wrongful death compensatory damages is to restore the beneficiaries to the position they would have occupied had there been no death"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0,
      "case_paths": [
        "/nc-app/58/0551-01"
      ]
    },
    {
      "cite": "344 S.E.2d 839",
      "category": "reporters:state_regional",
      "reporter": "S.E.2d",
      "year": 1986,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "punitive damages are available upon proof of the underlying tort and an element of aggravation"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0
    },
    {
      "cite": "81 N.C. App. 556",
      "category": "reporters:state",
      "reporter": "N.C. App.",
      "case_ids": [
        8524438
      ],
      "year": 1986,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "punitive damages are available upon proof of the underlying tort and an element of aggravation"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0,
      "case_paths": [
        "/nc-app/81/0556-01"
      ]
    },
    {
      "cite": "313 S.E.2d 160",
      "category": "reporters:state_regional",
      "reporter": "S.E.2d",
      "year": 1984,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "punitive damages serve the purposes of punishment and deterrence"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0
    },
    {
      "cite": "305 S.E.2d 734",
      "category": "reporters:state_regional",
      "reporter": "S.E.2d",
      "year": 1984,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "punitive damages serve the purposes of punishment and deterrence"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0
    },
    {
      "cite": "309 N.C. 192",
      "category": "reporters:state",
      "reporter": "N.C.",
      "case_ids": [
        4763169,
        4764848,
        4767347,
        4762776,
        4761567
      ],
      "year": 1984,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "punitive damages serve the purposes of punishment and deterrence"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0,
      "case_paths": [
        "/nc/309/0192-05",
        "/nc/309/0192-02",
        "/nc/309/0192-04",
        "/nc/309/0192-03",
        "/nc/309/0192-01"
      ]
    },
    {
      "cite": "300 S.E.2d 833",
      "category": "reporters:state_regional",
      "reporter": "S.E.2d",
      "year": 1984,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "punitive damages serve the purposes of punishment and deterrence"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0
    },
    {
      "cite": "61 N.C. App. 170",
      "category": "reporters:state",
      "reporter": "N.C. App.",
      "case_ids": [
        8520017
      ],
      "year": 1984,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "punitive damages serve the purposes of punishment and deterrence"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0,
      "case_paths": [
        "/nc-app/61/0170-01"
      ]
    },
    {
      "cite": "347 S.E.2d 462",
      "category": "reporters:state_regional",
      "reporter": "S.E.2d",
      "year": 1986,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "a separate issue for punitive damages was properly submitted to the jury, based on evidence of gross negligence"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0
    },
    {
      "cite": "318 N.C. 281",
      "category": "reporters:state",
      "reporter": "N.C.",
      "case_ids": [
        4735680,
        4736315,
        4735915,
        4739582
      ],
      "year": 1986,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "a separate issue for punitive damages was properly submitted to the jury, based on evidence of gross negligence"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0,
      "case_paths": [
        "/nc/318/0281-04",
        "/nc/318/0281-03",
        "/nc/318/0281-02",
        "/nc/318/0281-01"
      ]
    },
    {
      "cite": "344 S.E.2d 130",
      "category": "reporters:state_regional",
      "reporter": "S.E.2d",
      "year": 1986,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "a separate issue for punitive damages was properly submitted to the jury, based on evidence of gross negligence"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0
    },
    {
      "cite": "81 N.C. App. 213",
      "category": "reporters:state",
      "reporter": "N.C. App.",
      "case_ids": [
        8522224
      ],
      "year": 1986,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "a separate issue for punitive damages was properly submitted to the jury, based on evidence of gross negligence"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0,
      "case_paths": [
        "/nc-app/81/0213-01"
      ]
    },
    {
      "cite": "134 S.E.2d 186",
      "category": "reporters:state_regional",
      "reporter": "S.E.2d",
      "year": 1964,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "page": "190"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0
    },
    {
      "cite": "261 N.C. 31",
      "category": "reporters:state",
      "reporter": "N.C.",
      "case_ids": [
        8571586
      ],
      "year": 1964,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "page": "35"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0,
      "case_paths": [
        "/nc/261/0031-01"
      ]
    },
    {
      "cite": "92 S.E.2d 393",
      "category": "reporters:state_regional",
      "reporter": "S.E.2d",
      "year": 1956,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "page": "395",
          "parenthetical": "citation omitted"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0
    },
    {
      "cite": "244 N.C. 23",
      "category": "reporters:state",
      "reporter": "N.C.",
      "case_ids": [
        2219545
      ],
      "year": 1956,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "page": "26",
          "parenthetical": "citation omitted"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0,
      "case_paths": [
        "/nc/244/0023-01"
      ]
    },
    {
      "cite": "196 S.E.2d 789",
      "category": "reporters:state_regional",
      "reporter": "S.E.2d",
      "weight": 2,
      "year": 1973,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "discussing revision of the statute"
        },
        {
          "page": "807"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0
    },
    {
      "cite": "283 N.C. 395",
      "category": "reporters:state",
      "reporter": "N.C.",
      "case_ids": [
        8559175
      ],
      "year": 1973,
      "pin_cites": [
        {
          "parenthetical": "discussing revision of the statute"
        }
      ],
      "opinion_index": 0,
      "case_paths": [
        "/nc/283/0395-01"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "analysis": {
    "cardinality": 389,
    "char_count": 5994,
    "ocr_confidence": 0.766,
    "pagerank": {
      "raw": 8.685371297493976e-08,
      "percentile": 0.4927016980526664
    },
    "sha256": "7c3327143c2f0ab824cd66c2b545380337aca04c9d1d77fd0cefbef6d0631a78",
    "simhash": "1:2629deb23c6b0f5a",
    "word_count": 941
  },
  "last_updated": "2023-07-14T22:38:52.620321+00:00",
  "provenance": {
    "date_added": "2019-08-29",
    "source": "Harvard",
    "batch": "2018"
  },
  "casebody": {
    "judges": [
      "Judges Wells and Eagles concur."
    ],
    "parties": [
      "TERESA M. P. JONES and LOUISE BLANCHARD JONES, Co-Administratrixes of the Estate of KIM BLANCHARD JONES, Deceased v. FOSTER McCASKILL, III"
    ],
    "opinions": [
      {
        "text": "GREENE, Judge.\nPlaintiffs appeal and assign error to the trial court\u2019s submission to the jury the issue of punitive damages as a separate issue in this wrongful death suit.\nPlaintiffs are co-administratrixes of the estate of Kim Jones, who died on 16 August 1986. Record evidence shows that Jones was driving a motor vehicle which collided with defendant\u2019s motor vehicle. Jones died after suffering injuries in the collision.\nPlaintiffs filed suit, alleging that defendant\u2019s \u201cwillful, wanton and gross\u201d negligence caused Jones\u2019s wrongful death. Plaintiffs prayed recovery of compensatory and punitive damages as permitted by N.C.G.S. \u00a7 28A-18-2.\nAfter admission of evidence during trial and before the issues were submitted to the jury, plaintiffs objected and excepted to the trial court\u2019s submission of a punitive damages issue separate from the compensatory damages issue.\nThe court submitted, and the jury answered, these issues:\n1. Was Kim Blanchard Jones killed by negligence on the part of the Defendant Foster McCaskill, III?\nANSWER: Yes.\n2. What amount of damages are Teresa M. P. Jones and Louise Blanchard Jones, Co-Administratrixes of the Estate of Kim Blanchard Jones, deceased, entitled to recover by reason of the death of Kim Blanchard Jones?\nANSWER: $25,538.89.\n3. What amount of punitive damages, if any, does the jury in its discretion award to the Plaintiffs?\nANSWER: $75,000.00.\nThe sole issue is whether the trial court erred in submitting a separate issue on punitive damages.\nPlaintiffs contend that our wrongful death statute embodies the legislature\u2019s intent to require the court to submit only one damage issue to the jury. We disagree.\n\u201cDamages recoverable for death by wrongful act include . . . [s]uch punitive damages as the decedent could have recovered had he survived, and punitive damages for wrongfully causing the death of the decedent through maliciousness, wilful or wanton injury, or gross negligence . . .\u201d N.C.G.S. \u00a7 28A-18-2(b)(5) (1985).\nIn 1969, our legislature amended N.C.G.S. \u00a7 28A-18-2 to add punitive damages as an item of recoverable damage. See Bowen v. Constructors Equip. Rental Co., 283 N.C. 395, 196 S.E.2d 789 (1973) (discussing revision of the statute). Before and after this amendment, \u201c[t]he approved practice is to submit separately [to the jury] the issues [of] compensatory damages and [of] punitive damages.\u201d Hinson v. Dawson, 244 N.C. 23, 26, 92 S.E.2d 393, 395 (1956) (citation omitted) (wrongful death action); see also North Carolina Pattern Jury Instruction 106.55 (1986) (listing a separate issue for punitive damages). \u201c \u2018If the pleadings and evidence so warrant, an issue as to punitive damages should be submitted to the jury.\u2019 \u201d Allred v. Graves, 261 N.C. 31, 35, 134 S.E.2d 186, 190 (1964), citing Hinson; Cole v. Duke Power Co., 81 N.C. App. 213, 344 S.E.2d 130, review denied, 318 N.C. 281, 347 S.E.2d 462 (1986) (a separate issue for punitive damages was properly submitted to the jury, based on evidence of gross negligence).\nWe determine that in a wrongful death action, the trial court should submit to the jury separate issues for compensatory and punitive damages when the evidence supports submission of these issues.\nPunitive damages differ significantly from compensatory damages. Punitive damages require different proof and serve different purposes than compensatory damages. See Mazza v. Huffaker, 61 N.C. App. 170, 300 S.E.2d 833, review denied, 309 N.C. 192, 305 S.E.2d 734, reconsid. denied, 313 S.E.2d 160 (1984) (punitive damages serve the purposes of punishment and deterrence); Burns v. Forsyth County Hosp. Auth., Inc., 81 N.C. App. 556, 344 S.E.2d 839 (1986) (punitive damages are available upon proof of the underlying tort and an element of aggravation); cf. Scallon v. Hooper, 58 N.C. App. 551, 293 S.E.2d 843, cert. denied, 306 N.C. 744, 295 S.E.2d 480 (1982) (the purpose of wrongful death compensatory damages is to restore the beneficiaries to the position they would have occupied had there been no death).\nFurthermore, there exist other sound reasons for separating punitive and compensatory damage issues. See Bowen, at. 421, 196 S.E.2d at 807 (the issues of punitive damages, compensatory damages for decedent\u2019s care, treatment and hospitalization prior to death, and compensatory damages for decedent\u2019s pain and suffering prior to death should be separate issues to show \u201cwhether the recovery for these items would constitute general assets of the estate\u201d); J. Stein, Damages and Recovery, Personal Injury and Death Actions \u00a7 120 (1972) (an insurer may not be liable for punitive damages, based on insurance contract language).\nPlaintiffs rely on the Bowen decision as authority for their argument that \u201cthe language of the [wrongful death] statute evinces a legislative intent that all elements permitted be combined into one sum as damages \u2018for death by wrongful act,\u2019 \u201d which we find unpersuasive in light of our Supreme Court\u2019s decision in favor of separating the issues. See Bowen.\nThe trial court properly submitted separate issues of punitive and compensatory damage to the jury.\nNo error.\nJudges Wells and Eagles concur.",
        "type": "majority",
        "author": "GREENE, Judge."
      }
    ],
    "attorneys": [
      "Spears, Barnes, Baker, Wainio, Brown & Whaley, by Alexander H. Barnes and Mark A. Scruggs, and H. Wood Vann, for plaintiff-appellants.",
      "Reynolds, Bryant and Patterson, P.A., by Lee A. Patterson, II, for defendant-appellee."
    ],
    "corrections": "",
    "head_matter": "TERESA M. P. JONES and LOUISE BLANCHARD JONES, Co-Administratrixes of the Estate of KIM BLANCHARD JONES, Deceased v. FOSTER McCASKILL, III\nNo. 8915SC1117\n(Filed 7 August 1990)\nDeath \u00a7 7 (NCI3d)\u2014 wrongful death \u2014 separate issues of compensatory and punitive damages\nIn a wrongful death action the trial court should submit to the jury separate issues for compensatory and punitive damages when the evidence supports submission of these issues.\nAm Jur 2d, Death \u00a7\u00a7 526, 527.\nAPPEAL by plaintiffs from judgment entered 20 July 1989 by Judge F. Gordon Battle in ORANGE County Superior Court. Heard in the Court of Appeals 11 April 1990.\nSpears, Barnes, Baker, Wainio, Brown & Whaley, by Alexander H. Barnes and Mark A. Scruggs, and H. Wood Vann, for plaintiff-appellants.\nReynolds, Bryant and Patterson, P.A., by Lee A. Patterson, II, for defendant-appellee."
  },
  "file_name": "0764-01",
  "first_page_order": 794,
  "last_page_order": 797
}
