{ "id": 8658533, "name": "T. M. CLARK and MINNIE E. CLARK v. OLA A. BENTON, a minor, by guardian", "name_abbreviation": "Clark v. Benton", "decision_date": "1899-03-21", "docket_number": "", "first_page": "197", "last_page": "200", "citations": [ { "type": "official", "cite": "124 N.C. 197" } ], "court": { "name_abbreviation": "N.C.", "id": 9292, "name": "Supreme Court of North Carolina" }, "jurisdiction": { "id": 5, "name_long": "North Carolina", "name": "N.C." }, "cites_to": [ { "cite": "113 N. C., 513", "category": "reporters:state", "reporter": "N.C.", "case_ids": [ 8653512 ], "opinion_index": 0, "case_paths": [ "/nc/113/0513-01" ] } ], "analysis": { "cardinality": 302, "char_count": 4567, "ocr_confidence": 0.459, "pagerank": { "raw": 6.087085966315723e-08, "percentile": 0.3769735223945489 }, "sha256": "3fa8e23feca211d28a7ffd0e076696acdafa7d99b7c9ae4937731b5e1a8873ff", "simhash": "1:9f1544e7c7218294", "word_count": 826 }, "last_updated": "2023-07-14T20:09:58.946028+00:00", "provenance": { "date_added": "2019-08-29", "source": "Harvard", "batch": "2018" }, "casebody": { "judges": [], "parties": [ "T. M. CLARK and MINNIE E. CLARK v. OLA A. BENTON, a minor, by guardian." ], "opinions": [ { "text": "Clark, J.\nThis was a petition for partition, brought by T. M. Clark and Minnie E. Clark against Ola A. Benton (joining W. O. Benton, her guardian,) transferred to tbe Superior Court upon issues raised by tbe pleadings. Tbe result depends upon the proper construction of Items 2 and -4 of tbe will of Alexander Clark, deceased, which are as follows :\n\u201cItem 2. I will unto my son Alexander Clark as trustee,- and in trust to tbe use of my daughter Mary E. Lelmy during her lifetime, and then to her children, if she has any, and if not, to my two youngest children, Minnie Etta and Alice Rebecca, a piece of land bounded as follows: \u201cBeginning at an Elm, John Setzer\u2019s and my corner (here follows the boundaries) containing one hundred and fifty or sixty acres, more or less.\u201d\n\u201cItem 4. I will and bequeath unto my son Alexander Clark, as trustee, and in trust to the use of my beloved wife, Olarentine D., the balance of my home plantation, during her life, and then to my two daughters Minnie and Alice R.; and in case my wife should be in a family way and have a living child, it is to receive an equal part in the above land with Minnie E. and Alice R.\u201d\nIt was admitted that Alexander Clark died in the month of August, 1869.\n2. It was admitted that Troy M. Clark was twenty-six years of age at the comencement of this section, and is the posthumous son of Alexander Clark, the testator, born in a few months after his death, and is the person mentioned in the third paragraph of said will.\n3. It was admitted that Alice R. Clark died, leaving the defendant Ola A. Benton as her only child and heir-at-law, and that the said Alice R. Clark has married W. 0. Benton.\nIt is admitted that Minnie E. Clark is still living.\n5. The land sought to be partitioned is admited to be the same land as that described in the second paragraph of the will and in the petition.\n6. It was admitted on the trial that Mary E. Lemly died in 1896, without issue.\nThe defendant offered Alexander Clark as a witness,, who testified that he was the trustee mentioned in the second paragraph of the will, and that Mary E. Lemly received the rents of said land from the death of the testator to her death in 1896.\nIt is admitted that Troy M. Clark, the plaintiff, has never received any part of the rents of said land.\u201d\nUpon the foregoing evidence the Judge charged the jury that if they believed the evidence they should, in response to the issue, find that the plaintiffs, Troy M. Clark and Minnie E. Clark, and the defendant Ola A. Benton, were each entitled to one-third interest in the land in controversy (described in the second item of the will), and the defendant excepted.\nThere can be, in our opinion, no reasonable doubt that this was the intention of the testator. By the death of Mary Lemly without issue, the limitation over to Minnie and Alice took effect, and this tract of land became theirs under the will, as much so as that devised in the fourth item, and as such the plaintiff Troy M. Clark is entitled to one-third therein, which renders the share of the other plaintiff Minnie E. and the defendant Ola A. Benton likewise one-third each, instead of one-half each, as contended by the defendant.\nItem 4 gives the posthumous child (if there should be one) \u201can equal part with Minnie E. and Alice R. in the above land;\u201d i. e. not merely in the land devised to them by that clause, but in all that was given them by the will.\nBeing tenants in common, nothing less than adverse possession for twenty years would bar the plaintiffs\u2019 right of partition. Lenoir v. Mining Co., 113 N. C., 513. Indeed, that defence seems to have been abandoned.\nAffirmed.", "type": "majority", "author": "Clark, J." } ], "attorneys": [ "Mr. J. B. Connelly, for defendant (appellant).", "Messrs. Armfielcl & Turner and L. G. Caldwell, for plaintiffs." ], "corrections": "", "head_matter": "T. M. CLARK and MINNIE E. CLARK v. OLA A. BENTON, a minor, by guardian.\n(Decided March 21, 1899).\nConstruction of Will \u2014 Posthumous Child.\nWhere it can be gathered from the will that it was the intention of the testator that a posthumous child should share equally with his two children, in esse, the Court will effectuate his intention.\nPetitioN EOR PaRtitioN of land filed before tbe Clerk of Iredell Superior Court, and transferred to Term, and beard before Melver, J., at May Term, 1898.\nTbe parties all claimed under tbe will of Alexander Clark. T. M. Clark was a posthumous child. Tbe decision of tbe 'cause involved tbe proper construction of tbis will. ITis Honor decided that they all shared equally, each taking one-third. The defendant excepted and appealed.\nA copy of tbe will appears in tbe opinion.\nMr. J. B. Connelly, for defendant (appellant).\nMessrs. Armfielcl & Turner and L. G. Caldwell, for plaintiffs." }, "file_name": "0197-01", "first_page_order": 225, "last_page_order": 228 }