#### HENRY O. WOMACK v. S. O. THORNE, WADE W. WELCH, GRINNELL COMPANY, Incorporated, and GENERAL FIRE EXTINGUISHER COMPANY.

(Filed 22 November, 1933.)

Appeal by plaintiff from Oowper, Special Judge, at June Term, 1933, of MeckleNbueg.

Affirmed.

Taliaferro & Clarkson and Carsivell & Ervin for plaintif.

O. H. Gover and William T. Covington, Jr., for defendants.

Pee Cueiam.

This was a motion made by the defendants for tho removal of the action to the United States District Court for the Western District of North Carolina for improper joinder of parties plaintiff. The clerk of the Superior Court allowed the motion and on appeal to the Superior Court the judgment was affirmed. The plaintiff appealed to the Supreme Court assigning error. The judgment of the Superior Court is affirmed. Brown v. R. R., 204 N. C., 25; Culp v. Ins. Co., 202 N. C., 87; Overton v. R. R., ibid., 848; Matthews v. Lumber Co., 198 N. C., 129; Wright v. Utility Co., ibid., 204; Ferris v. R. R., 194 N. C., 653.

Affirmed.