#### ADELAIDE C. BROWN v. THE EQUITABLE LIFE ASSURANCE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES, MRS. JOHN LEONARD BROWN, MRS. GRACE BROWN SAUNDERS, and MISS MAUDE BROWN.

(Filed 29 April, 1936.)

Appeal and Error J d—

Where the Supreme Court is evenly divided in opinion, one Justice not sitting, the judgment of the lower court will be affirmed without becoming a precedent.

Clarkson, J., not sitting.

Appeal by defendants from Daniels, J., at March Term, 1935, of "Wake.

Affirmed.

This was an action instituted by plaintiff against the defendants to recover the proceeds of a certain life insurance policy written by the corporate defendant upon the life of Louis A. Brown, now deceased. The plaintiff’s claim to the proceeds of said policy was based upon an allegation and contention that a purported assignment of the policy to Louis A. Brown, her husband, signed by her,'was void for the reason that it carried with it a warranty and was not executed in conformity to section 2515 of the Consolidated Statutes. The defendants denied said allegation and contended that the assignment of the policy to Louis A. Brown was in all respects regular and valid.

From judgment for the plaintifE the defendants appealed to the Supreme Court.

Douglass & Douglass for plaintiff, appellee.

Hartsell & Hartsell for individual defendants, appellants.

S. Brown Shepherd and Wm. Vass Shepherd for the corporate defendant, appellant.

Per Curiam.

The Court being evenly divided in opinion, Mr. Judie e Clarkson not sitting, the judgment of the Superior Court is affirmed and stands as the decision in this case, without becoming a precedent. Hayes v. Hickory, 208 N. C., 845, and cases there cited.

Affirmed.

ClaricsoN, J., not sitting.